Make an Authentic Coney Dog in Your Own Kitchen
Use this short ingredient list and easy step-by-step method to put together a classic Coney dog the traditional way: a steamed bun, a quality wiener, yellow mustard, Original Coney sauce, and chopped sweet onions.
Ingredients You'll Need
- Steamed bun
- Quality wiener
- Yellow mustard
- Original Coney sauce
- Chopped sweet onions
Step-by-Step Directions
- Place the dog inside a steamed bun.
- Spread yellow mustard over the dog.
- Top with Nick's Original Coney Island Hot Dog Sauce® and finish with sweet onions.
- Serve and enjoy!
Common Questions About a "True" Coney
What makes a hot dog a "true" Coney?
Based on the ingredients and directions above, a true Coney starts with a steamed bun and a quality wiener, then gets topped with yellow mustard, Nick's Original Coney Island Hot Dog Sauce®, and chopped sweet onions.
What ingredients do I need to make one?
Only a few things: a steamed bun, a quality wiener, yellow mustard, Original Coney sauce, and chopped sweet onions.
In what order should I build the Coney?
Put the dog in a steamed bun, add yellow mustard, then spoon on Nick's Original Coney Island Hot Dog Sauce® and finish with sweet onions. Then eat and enjoy.
Do I need to steam the bun?
Yes — the directions above call for placing the dog in a steamed bun, so steaming is part of the preparation described here.
Where can I learn more about the sauce and other ways to use it?
Check out Nick's Sauce, Preparation, and Other Recipe Ideas for more, or head to the shop to order Nick's Coney sauce.
Once you've mastered the classic build, the same steamed bun, mustard, and sweet onion approach works as a starting point for experimenting with your own Coney variations. Keep Nick's Original Coney Island Hot Dog Sauce® on hand so a true Coney is always a few minutes away.